The Best Screwdriver Set Ever Tested!

Project Farm Mar 30, 2025 1.47 Million views
Watch on YouTube

Description

Snap On, Craftsman, GearWrench, Duratech, Mayhew, Stahlwille, Wiha, DeWalt, Kobalt, Williams, GreatNeck, ValueMax, Black+Decker, Pittsburgh, and Amartisan. Screwdrivers compared for performance on Phillips and slotted screws. The screwdrivers were also compared for maximum handle force. I purchased all of the screwdrivers to ensure an unbiased review. So, thank you for supporting the channel. ➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel through Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/projectfarm ➡ Thank you for supporting the channel through memberships: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2rzsm1Qi6N1X-wuOg_p0Ng/join ➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: http://bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together. ➡ Facebook Project Farm: https://www.facebook.com/people/Project-Farm/100084004365959/ ➡ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@realprojectfarm?_t=8oA53IvDBz5\u0026_r=1 ➡ Merch: project-farm.com ➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2rzsm1Qi6N1X-wuOg_p0Ng?sub_confirmation=1 ➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. ➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order): Craftsman: https://amzn.to/40ZHlsC Mayhew: https://amzn.to/3D10l1Q Duratech: https://amzn.to/4hAnJST GearWrench: https://amzn.to/4aVQVRM Stahlwille: https://amzn.to/4jXrhAj Wiha: https://amzn.to/3ECugOA Knipex: https://amzn.to/4jUOKlK DeWalt: https://amzn.to/4jXPDtW Kobalt: https://amzn.to/40XbM2F Williams: https://amzn.to/3D0gzZ7 GreatNeck: https://amzn.to/3WWGGXP ValueMax: https://amzn.to/3CJDdVH Black+Decker: https://amzn.to/3QeEvuL Armartisan: https://amzn.to/4jTXxo2 Pittsburgh: Available at Harbor Freight Snap On: Available at the online Snap On store Videography Equipment: Canon EOS R6 Mark II: https://amzn.to/4aErF18 Canon 70D Camera: https://amzn.to/31b5Gy0 Azden Microphone: https://amzn.to/34d3DLE Go Pro Bundle: https://amzn.to/3Ca0ZVN This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results.

Products Reviewed (32)

Extreme Grip Diamond Tip Screwdriver Set
Winner

Craftsman

Extreme Grip Diamond Tip Screwdriver Set

$50.00

#1 5.0

Best Overall - Won overall competition with average finish of 3.3. Diamond tip provides exceptional grip - 'by far the best grip on the screws'. Achieved 110 inch-pounds average torque, highest in Phillips test. 6-piece set with 3 slotted and 3 Phillips drivers.

Extreme Grip Diamond Tip Screwdriver Set
Winner

Craftsman

Extreme Grip Diamond Tip Screwdriver Set

$50.00

#1 5.0

Best Overall - Average finish of 3.3. Diamond tip offers four times more gripping power than standard black oxide finish. Best grip performance at 103 inch pounds tightening, 117 inch pounds loosening for average of 110 inch pounds. Diamonds made huge positive difference preventing cam out.

Magnetic Screwdriver Set
Winner

Duratech

Magnetic Screwdriver Set

$30.00

#2 4.0

Best Value - Tied for fourth place but highlighted as best value. Second place in Phillips test at 97 inch-pounds. 12-piece set with demagnetizer and offset screwdriver. Made of S2 alloy steel, made in China.

Magnetic Screwdriver Set
Winner

Duratech

Magnetic Screwdriver Set

$30.00

#2 4.5

Best Value - Tied for 4th with average finish. Best value option - comprehensive set outperforming many expensive brands. Phillips: 89 inch pounds tightening, 105 inch pounds loosening (97 average). All 50 screws went in without slipping. Made in China.

Capped End Screwdriver Set

Mayhew

Capped End Screwdriver Set

$41.00

#3 4.5

Second place overall with average finish of 3.7. Excellent all-around performance at reasonable price. Won slotted screwdriver test at 153 inch-pounds. 6-piece set with black oxide tip, hex bolstered for wrench use, made in Taiwan.

Capped End Screwdriver Set

Mayhew

Capped End Screwdriver Set

$41.00

#3 4.5

Average finish of 3.7. Great all-around screwdriver at reasonable price. Phillips: 78 inch pounds tightening, 93 inch pounds loosening. Slotted won at 153 inch pounds maximum torque. Made in Taiwan with hex bolstered design.

Dual Material Screwdriver Set

GearWrench

Dual Material Screwdriver Set

$52.00

#4 4.0

Tied for fourth place. Phillips-only set with 9 pieces. Features speed zone handle for faster rotation and non-slip black oxide tip. Good grip performance but not as good as Craftsman. Made in China.

Snap-On

ACR Tip Screwdriver Set

$265.55

#4 4.0

Third place finish at 95 inch pounds average. Phillips: 96 inch pounds tightening before tip snapped at 94 inch pounds loosening. Flutes looked as good as new after tests. Made in USA. Most expensive at $265.55 after shipping.

Snap-on

ACR Tip Screwdriver Set

$265.55

#5 4.0

Third place in Phillips test at 95 inch-pounds. Premium price at $265.55 after shipping. 8-piece set with trilobite handle design and special alloy steel. Flutes looked 'as good as new' after testing. Made in USA.

Dual Material Phillips Screwdriver Set

GearWrench

Dual Material Phillips Screwdriver Set

$52.00

#5 4.0

Tied for 4th place but doesn't include slotted screwdrivers. Phillips: 84 inch pounds tightening, 93 inch pounds loosening. Speed zone handle for faster rotation. Very good grip but not as good as Craftsman.

Screwdriver Set

Wiha

Screwdriver Set

$99.00

#6 4.0

Second place in slotted test at 146 inch-pounds. 7-piece set with CRM72 tool steel and striking cap. Features parallel flats for rolloff prevention. Performed flawlessly with no cam-outs. Made in Germany.

CRM72 Tool Steel Screwdriver Set

Wiha

CRM72 Tool Steel Screwdriver Set

$99.00

#6 4.0

Phillips: 76 inch pounds tightening, 80 inch pounds loosening. Performed just as flawlessly as Stahlwille - no cam outs while installing 50 screws. Heavy duty hex blade with CRM72 tool steel. Made in Germany.

Screwdriver Set

Stahlwille

Screwdriver Set

$92.00

#7 4.0

Excellent performance with no slipping or cam-outs during installation. 6-piece set with industrial-grade chrome alloy steel. Through hardened blades. Performed almost as well as top brands. Made in Germany.

Chrome Alloy Steel Screwdriver Set

Stahlwille

Chrome Alloy Steel Screwdriver Set

$92.00

#7 4.0

Did not slip or cam out single time installing screws. Phillips: 78 inch pounds tightening, 89 inch pounds loosening. Exceptionally fine industrial-grade chrome alloy steel, through hardened. Made in Germany.

1000 Volt Insulated Screwdriver Set

Knipex

1000 Volt Insulated Screwdriver Set

$70.00

#8 3.5

Third place in slotted test at 145 inch-pounds. 6-piece insulated set for electrical work. Black oxide finish tips. Performed better than most brands but not as good as Craftsman. Made in Germany.

1000V Insulated Screwdriver Set

Knipex

1000V Insulated Screwdriver Set

$70.00

#8 4.0

Phillips: 68 inch pounds tightening, 83 inch pounds loosening (76 average). German-made performing better than most brands but not as good as Craftsman. 1000V insulated with black oxide finish.

Enduro Grip Multi-Size Screwdriver Set

Williams

Enduro Grip Multi-Size Screwdriver Set

$71.00

#9 3.0

Won handle force test at 1,595 pounds but struggled with grip performance. 8-piece set with chrome blades and hex bolsters. Started strong but began struggling on last few screws. Made in USA.

S2 Steel Screwdriver Set

DeWalt

S2 Steel Screwdriver Set

$34.00

#9 3.5

Phillips: 79 inch pounds tightening, 69 inch pounds loosening. S2 steel bar for increased durability. Black chrome plated for 10x better rust resistance. Made in Taiwan with solid steel core and metal strike cap.

Screwdriver Set

DeWalt

Screwdriver Set

$34.00

#10 3.0

8-piece set with black chrome plating for rust resistance. S2 steel bar for durability. Performed about average overall but lost grip near end of tests. Metal strike cap for demolition work. Made in Taiwan.

Enduro Grip Multi-Size Screwdriver Set

Williams

Enduro Grip Multi-Size Screwdriver Set

$71.00

#10 3.0

Phillips: 61 inch pounds tightening, 65 inch pounds loosening. Started strong but began struggling on last few screws. Special alloy steel blades with hex bolsters. Made in USA. Won handle force test at 1,595 pounds.

Screwdriver Set

Great Neck

Screwdriver Set

$30.00

#11 2.5

Second place in handle force test at 1,561 pounds despite starting damage at 400 pounds. 10-piece set with impact resistant handles and magnetic tips. Required more downward force on final screws. Made in Taiwan.

Impact Resistant Screwdriver Set

Great Neck

Impact Resistant Screwdriver Set

$30.00

#11 3.0

Phillips: 70 inch pounds tightening, 84 inch pounds loosening. Required more downward force on final 10 screws. Precision machined with fluted handle design. Made in Taiwan. Second in handle force at 1,561 pounds.

Black Oxide Screwdriver Set

Black+Decker

Black Oxide Screwdriver Set

$18.00

#12 3.0

17-piece set for just over $1 per screwdriver. Black oxide tips reduce slipping and stripping. Maintained much better grip than cheapest options. Chrome-plated for rust resistance. Made in China.

Heat Treated Chrome Vanadium Screwdriver Set

Kobalt

Heat Treated Chrome Vanadium Screwdriver Set

$37.00

#12 2.5

Started strong but faded near end. Phillips screwdriver extremely brittle, broke at only 63 inch pounds. Slotted performed better at 136 inch pounds. Heat treated chrome vanadium steel with black oxide tip. Made in China.

Heat Treated Screwdriver Set

Kobalt

Heat Treated Screwdriver Set

$37.00

#13 2.5

20-piece set with heat treated chrome vanadium steel. Started strong but performance faded near end. Phillips screwdriver broke at only 63 inch-pounds. Black oxide magnetic tips. Made in China.

Black Oxide Tip Screwdriver Set

Black & Decker

Black Oxide Tip Screwdriver Set

$18.00

#13 3.5

Phillips: 52 inch pounds tightening, 70 inch pounds loosening (61 average). Black oxide coating adds grip, required less downward force than first three brands. Chrome plated to resist rust. Made in China.

Top Quality Magnetic Screwdriver Set

Amartisan

Top Quality Magnetic Screwdriver Set

$10.00

#14 2.0

10-piece set that broke during screw removal test after removing only 38 screws due to metal fatigue. Claims premium chrome vanadium steel materials. Could not complete full testing. Made in China.

Magnetic Screwdriver Set

Value Max

Magnetic Screwdriver Set

$8.00

#14 2.0

Phillips tip broke at 78 inch pounds. Made of very soft steel, losing grip quickly. Barely survived all 50 screws, couldn't remove 1 screw. Non-slip handle, chrome vanadium steel. Made in China.

Pittsburgh

Screwdriver Set

$8.00

#15 2.0

12-piece set from Harbor Freight for same $8 as Value Max. Chrome vanadium steel with magnetic tips. Could not remove 2 screws even with 100 pounds of downward force. Performance faded quickly due to soft steel.

Pittsburgh

Chrome Vanadium Steel Screwdriver Set

$8.00

#15 2.0

Phillips: 20 inch pounds tightening, 6 inch pounds loosening. Pretty much worn out after tests. Couldn't remove 2 of 50 screws. Made of soft steel, lost grip quickly. 12 screwdrivers for $8. Made in China.

Magnetic Screwdriver Set

Value Max

Magnetic Screwdriver Set

$8.00

#16 1.5

6-piece budget set that barely survived 50 screws. Made of very soft steel, losing grip quickly. Could not remove one screw completely. Chrome vanadium steel construction. Worst overall performer. Made in China.

Top Quality Magnetic Screwdriver Set

Amartisan

Top Quality Magnetic Screwdriver Set

$10.00

#16 1.5

Screwdriver broke after removing only 38 screws due to metal fatigue. Claims premium materials but performed worst. 10 screwdrivers with cushion grip handle. Made in China.